Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I love how people get so angry when they don't get the answers they were looking for. Alva was right when she said the OP is looking for how to make her husband more comfortable with the decision she has made. She doesn't care about her husband's comfort at all. He tried it for 8 months but decided he can't do this anymore. Give him some credit for at least trying. My advice is to let him move back home and give you 6 months to figure out a plan B for your Dad before going back home yourself.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
lealonnie1 Apr 27, 2024
I give the dh a lot of credit for his 8 months of time served, honestly. Much more than most would do.
(10)
Report
See 4 more replies
I'm not sure how bullying this women is helping her in anyway!!

Did you all forget what it's like to be burntout!!

It's not fun
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
funkygrandma59 Apr 27, 2024
Anxietynacy, NO ONE has been bullying this OP whatsoever. I'm not sure what you're referring to. We are all just being honest, though the Op doesn't seem to appreciate all our honesty. Perhaps in time she will, when things slowly start to unravel in her life.
And I don't get the impression that the OP is burned out at all, but is just wanting all of us to give her suggestions to make her husband stay in this unhealthy living arrangement that is no longer working for him.
She seems to be enjoying caring for her dad and all it entails, it is her husband that is causing her problems because he wants his old life back in his own home.
Sometimes the truth can be harsh, but often it is just what needs to be said, whether the OP's like it or not.
(5)
Report
See 4 more replies
Is there a possibility that your husband, at his age, sees how your Dad is rapidly declining and is experiencing some decline in himself? This could bring on fear, anxiety, and a strong need to escape, a realistic need to reevaluate just how his later years are to be spent? 🕺🤵‍♂️👨‍🦳️👴🏃‍♂️🚶‍♂️🤷‍♂️

It is unfair, imo, to be criticizing your husband (what kind of a man is he?) just because he chooses to return home and not be a part of your caregiving plan.

Not to be taking sides here, just exploring the dynamics of the many things
that can go wrong. If it does not fit your situation, just ignore.

👨‍🦳️👩‍🦳️
👴👵

Maybe a visit to your doctors for each of you is called for?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

If DH isn’t happy with this after 8 months, he isn’t going to become ‘more comfortable’ if nothing changes with you and F. Have you thought about what changes YOU could make. Perhaps just stop talking about F - particularly just as DH walks in the door? You talked about it for months before you made the move, I'm not surprised that DH is sick and tired of the whole thing. I can imagine F's ghostly presence hanging over your whole house. Talking about F shouldn't be the most important thing in your life.

Set yourself a challenge. Go for 24 hours (or 48 hours or even a week) without mentioning F to DH. If you find it difficult, you have an answer to your question.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
lkdrymom Apr 27, 2024
Excellent idea. This man did not think his retirement years would be all about his father in law.
(2)
Report
I think you have your answer.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

So after talking to your husband about your dad why is he so angry and resentful of your father? What is the reason he doesn't even want to be in the same room with him? Did something happen? Was something said? Just curious how your husband went from getting along with dad to pretty much disliking him so much he can't stand to look at him. From what you say dad is not low maintenance since he needs help with cooking, cleaning, medications and bathing. Do you know what is going on with husband? Have you asked him? Was this supposed to be temporary or permanent?

My grandma lived with my parents for about 20 years and over time little things grandma did (and vice versa with my dad saying or not saying things) or said just built up the resentment and anger over time and both had a lot of animosity. Dad didn't want to kick her out but he also didn't think she would be there for 20 years in his house.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

CaringforDad, I’ve now read you previous reply, and yes I guess your question wasn’t written correctly, as you said. Your question says that your husband has ‘progressively gotten angrier’ and is now ‘resentful’ and ‘jealous of my dad’, to the point where ‘he is insisting we put dad in AL and move back home’. That doesn’t sound as though a few ‘trivia nights and karaoke nights and sometimes live music’ will make everything right. Church and prayer may help more than karaoke, depending on the strength of your faith, but it’s a long shot. The Bible’s ‘honor thy father and thy mother’ (through multiple language translations of complex concepts) seems to be about ‘be respectful in public, don’t run them down’, not have them to live with you and build your world around them.

The poster who asked if you were ‘sleeping with your Dad’ wasn’t suggesting that you WERE doing that, just making the point that it’s yet another thing you do with husbands, and that there’s a big difference in the relationships. I'm quite shocked that you seem to take this as a genuine incest allegation.

If you don’t want to change, we can only wish you luck. And also hope that DH finds himself a life that satisfies him more, without transferring his unhappiness to you and your father. It does seem a pity to break up a good marriage over this. He has tried quite hard.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

True story. A few years back, a friend had a two car garage and was trying to figure out how to get two cars and a boat in it. He asked us, his friends, for advice on how to do it. We said you simply cannot do it. It is a big two car garage, but the simple arithmetic (measure widths of vehicles) doesnt allow that. This guy was not stupid, but figured creative minds could figure out a solution. He thought if you backed the boat and then drove cars in at a certain angle it might be done.

It reminds me of this post. The OP has a sincere desire of how she can make this work and for that she should be admired. But while in this case the issue is not physical space, it is emotional space, etc and it simply cannot be done, three humans in one space, just like two cars and a boat cannot be garaged in a two car garage.

The friend had to decide which vehicle should not be garaged at his home.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report
KNance72 Apr 27, 2024
Good analogy Karsten
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
The size of your dad’s house or arranging to spend leisure time in separate rooms is not making this easier for your husband. I believe your husband wants to go back to his house, his home - now. Ideally with you. Maybe your siblings can take over care for longer periods of time at the least.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

At first, it seems like a good idea to help dad, because he needs help. And that's nice of your husband to agree. You have both tried to make this work.
It's difficult for your husband though because he needs to share his wife with someone else. You can't do certain things that you would at home, like go out whenever. Or hubby might be talking to you and then dad calls your name.

I know from experience awhile ago, residing with hubby and dad. Hubby and I want to relax and my dad was screaming in the next room.

Parents shouldn't come between a marriage. We love our parents. But marriage is sacred and should be respected.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My husband and I sold our house and moved into my fathers basement 4 years ago
I was scared of your situation before we moved in
I have someone who comes into our home and cares for my father and my husband and I go on a date
I have one sister who will come and care for our dad while my husband and I get away for a few days
Being a caregiver is the most difficult job I’ve ever had but it’s a huge balancing game
You need to make your husband feel like a priority, and you need a break as well, a mental health break
When your dad passes, you are going to need him, your friend, your partner
I wish only health and happiness to you both
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
KNance72 Apr 28, 2024
Nice response and good advice Trish
(1)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter