Find Senior Care (City or Zip)
Join Now Log In
J
Judy79 Asked September 2019

Favoritism? Frustrated.

How much favoritism is in this group? Do you choose who you respond to and who you don't? If someone has a legitimate complaint, do you listen or ignore? Reason for these questions is that when I started in this, my questions were being answered. Now, hardly get any answers. Unless hardly anyone is logged into this. I have genuine concerns. Might be griping at times, but it's still legitimate.


Tired of my brother wanting to take charge of everything in relation to my mother. His also. I want to see what the money is being used for. I don't want to confront him and ask him. He might think and say that it's non of my business. But I am her daughter and I have been living with her longer than he did. He is realizing how much is involved with being a POA. But in reality, he isn't doing everything that a POA is supposed to do, IF he is POA over everything. And how would I tell his wife to stay out of our business? If it was her mother in this position, I don't think that she would want her husband interfering either. But she surely has been doing it with me. And he doesn't even know about it. Should I tell and show him or keep him in the dark?

Geaton777 Sep 2019
Judy, I have just recently been active on this site. I mostly don't answer questions in areas that I feel i have no real expertise or experience or wisdom to provide. I will confess that if the posts are long, rambling, and full of rantings about dysfunctional family dynamics, suspicions, jealousies and immaturities, i don't respond as there is no reasonable way to answer those, they're just too messy. Also sometimes I sense it is really about the money, and not what is in the best interest of the LO. In regards to your post here, it seems you don't trust your mom's judgment, or your brother. Like AlvaDeer has said, there's 2 sides to every story and without personally knowing the people involved there's nothing we can say that will be truly helpful to your mom's situation except just try trusting your bro. If he's giving you real reasons to suspect theft or fraud then hire an attorney. If not, then let it go. If you love your mom, be a source of peace -- and not drama -- in your family. Wishing you wisdom, trust, peace and harmony.

Ahmijoy Sep 2019
Judy, I am very sorry if any of your posts don’t get answered. Your name is not familiar to me as a frequent poster. We do not “play favorites” here and if your posts were not answered, perhaps there was a glitch in the posting of them.

The POA you speak of is between your mother and your brother. She appointed him and as those of us who have a POA have done, he is most likely doing the best he can. Husband’s and wives tend to talk things out between themselves and this is most likely what he and his wife are doing. When I was POA for my mom, I always bounced ideas off my husband. Telling tales on your sister-in-law to your brother could backfire on you.

Your brother should be keeping all receipts for any expenses to prove Mom’s money is being spent on her. He could be asked to show those receipts. But, that is between him, any attorneys that might be involved and any courts. He does not have to share those financial records to anyone else.

Keep your own council until and if you have solid proof that he is mishandling any of your mother’s finances. You sound as if you aren’t even sure what form of POA he has. Do not try to stir things up between him and his wife. What would that prove or solve? If and when you have proof he is mishandling your mother’s finances, enlist the help of an attorney and go to him/her with that proof.

ADVERTISEMENT


rocketjcat Sep 2019
Judy I have looked back at your profile and all the questions you initiated have had multiple answers. You can do this too by clicking on your profile and click on the Following tab. Please check it out to make sure a question you thought posted isn’t missing. There is no favoritism on this board, people respond to issues that they have familiarity with, or just touch their heart. I do remember responding to some of your questions myself, when you brought up the issue that your Mom is in an unlicensed facility that your brother chose, and now her long term care policy won’t pay. Has this been resolved? Is this the source of your displeasure with his handling of her finances? Do you have a copy of her policy so you can be familiar with exactly what the requirements/triggers are? Mine is very specific. If it all boils down to this, I agree with other posters that you could attempt to have her change POA to yourself if she’s of sound mind, and try to get her moved, but I think I would start with consulting your own lawyer (policy in hand) for advise.

BarbBrooklyn Sep 2019
Judy; I just read through some of your posts and they all seem to have answers.

In one, you ask why you don't have a copy of your mother's will and that you are tired of asking your SIL.

You have no right to your mother's will until she is dead and it is filed. I never saw my mom's will until it was entered into probate, nor should I.

Your brother, as POA, has a duty to keep your mother's finances private. Perhaps you didn't understand that.

Countrymouse Sep 2019
Judy, only speaking for myself but I tend to look first at the topics in the right hand margin, catch up on anything I left unattended previously, then if there's time - and I'm terrible for sidetracking myself - scan the forum.

I probably need to get a life... But this forum saved mine, and I love the people here, and the ones I think don't love me quite so much I try not to rub up the wrong way, and on the VERY rare occasions when I've really felt myself get annoyed I just close that thread and leave it alone.

I think it's worth bearing in mind that most forum members are under stress one way or another; plus that we each have our particular corns and sore patches and bugbears; and that we can't see facial expressions or hear tones of voice so sometimes misunderstandings are bound to happen.

But I'm CERTAIN SURE that you are not being intentionally avoided! :) Hugs to you.
staceyb2 Sep 2019
I Love you CM! ❤
Ahmijoy Sep 2019
Judy, IS there any issue here? Barb’s post of your statements and her comments is very concise. I understand that you want to help, but you might be presenting it in a way to your brother that sounds like interference to him. Do you have ANY concrete proof that he is mishandling anything? There may not be any need for helping him. By helping, do you mean you want to know everything that is going on? As was said, your brother has a duty as POA to keep your mother’s finances and affairs private. If her bills are being paid, why do you need to know what her financial situation is? My dad always said, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” And, I don’t think anything is broken here.

katiekat2009 Sep 2019
If your brother is doing a decent job as POA, you have been given a blessing. I would leave him (and his wife) be, offer to help where you can, and just be a daughter to your mother. Let him know you are available to help but stay out of his business. My SIL (a nurse) was a Godsend when my mom needed care. I thank the Lord she was available.
Judy79 Sep 2019
But you don't know our family history. I'm trying to do the best that I can. I feel that my mom's dementia is getting worse. She doesn't even remember that she has a partial in her mouth. She went to the dentist today.
If his wife starts interfering again, my husband will tell her to butt out. It's his mother not hers.
BarbBrooklyn Sep 2019
Judy;

In your last post (the one where you are surprised that you have "ticked off" one of the posters here, you write in a very confusing manner, mentioning "she" several times. It's really hard to figure out if your husband is going to yell at your SIL or your mom for being out of line.

I responded to a previous post of yours about something that your sister in law said to you that you seemed to take umbrage at. To my way of looking at it, she was expressing an opinion, not putting you down. Of course I wasn't there, but from reading and responding your posts, you seem to frequently cast yourself in the role of the victim.

Do you want Power of Attorney? Tell your brother that you would be happy to take on the job and both of you go to mom and have her change it.

What is your SIL butting in about? As I've previously written, my SIL handled almost all of my mom's finances (my brother was POA) because she was much more expert in that area and she was able to handle mom's money in a much more dispassionate way than were the rest of us. (To her, it was just money; my brother's and I were brought up in such a way that money had a lot of hidden and unspoken emotion attached--not in a good way).

Do you think mom's money is being spent frivolously? I never questioned how my mom's money was being spent, because it was HER money and she trusted my brother to spend it. We were brought up without expectation of an inheritance, so I wasn't counting her pennies. We made sure that the nursing home she was in would accept Medicaid after two years of private pay, so that we wouldn't have to move her, but what is brother spending money on that you object to? Are you being reimbursed for anything you lay out for her? Is brother being similarly reimbursed?

What is it that your SIL is communicating to you that you'd like to "show" your brother?

anonymous912123 Sep 2019
If I feel that I have something to add to a post, I will reply, otherwise I do not respond. So many of these posts are just rants, or the poster wants to draw a line in the sand, caretaking at home vrs placing the patient in a home. This is a topic that really has no right or wrong answer.

As for your question, if you feel that your brother is not doing what he needs to do, then I would talk to him. Your mother offered you to be the POA and you state that he is smarter than you, if he is, maybe he is doing the right things for your mother, and you are not aware of them.

There seems to be some dysfunction going on between you and your brother, why not address it before it gets out of hand.

My brother has my step-fathers POA, I ask him anything and everything, we discuss issues and how to handle them, we are a team, working together to take proper care of him and his wife. There is no dissention, to me, that is counter productive and accomplishes nothing.

JoAnn29 Sep 2019
I looked over some of the posts and one stood out. Replying to another post with a question. These type of posts get overlooked and sometimes take the thread in another direction. All questions should be a new post.

Be aware too, that some of us live in the UK and have an 8 hr difference or more.

See All Answers

ADVERTISEMENT

Ask a Question

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter