Find Senior Care (City or Zip)
Join Now Log In
S
Sat2018 Asked June 2022

Is a doctor required to inform you if they are speaking in front of a patient?

My mother has severe congestive heart failure and increasingly worse dementia and a decision needs to be made about treating her. The cardiologist has been pushing to try putting in stents just so he can get her out of the hospital as quickly as possible and keep her from coming back. However, since her mental health is steadily declining to the point she is a risk to herself, I'm not sure that prolonging her life physically is the humane thing to do. He called today again to try and push me to make a decision about surgery and I pointed out several things about her mental health and said I wanted to consult the psychiatrist that has been treating her before making a decision. About half an hour later I get a call from my mother basically telling me that I had been listening to the bad people and how could I believe the awful things they say about her. How I was a huge disappointment and even though she loved me as her daughter there was nothing left for us as far as a relationship. I couldn't figure out what was going on and called her nurse only to find out that when the cardiologist called me he was standing in her room and never bothered to tell me that. So our entire conversation was overheard and she knows I have concerns about her mental health. She is in complete denial that she has any issues and now views me as a traitor. I'm her only child. She has no other family and if she refuses to have anything to do with me going forward. There is literally nobody to help her and I feel like it's all this doctor's fault. Not to mention the fact that she will die thinking that I betrayed her when all I've been trying to do is what best for her but she's incapable of understanding that.

BarbBrooklyn Jun 2022
Sat, can you request a different cardiologist? A second opinion is often advisable in the case of surgery on someone this old.

Have you asked the hospitality for a palliative care evaluation?

Get hold of the patient advocate at the hospital. Have her/him look over mom's last several discharges. Explain how non-compliant she is.

Background-- if a patient comes back to the hospital within 30 days for the same ailment, Medicare stops paying. The bean counters are almost certainly on cardiologist back about stopping this revolving door.

Getting her on hospice/palliative will stop this.
Sat2018 Jun 2022
Thanks, I didn't know that about medicare. I was planning to call her case manager and inquire about hospice/pallative.
Countrymouse Jun 2022
I expect the cardiologist believes that the stents would improve your mother's heart function and thereby improve the blood supply to her brain. You may find the surgery results in a significant improvement in her mental condition, as well as preventing her recurrent trips to hospital.

I think you're going to find it difficult to make a complaint about breach of confidentiality when the person who overheard the conversation was the patient. The doctor's duty of care in this is to his patient, not to you.

I'm puzzled, though - if your mother is already seeing a psychiatrist and has been co-operating with those consultations, how can she have been unaware that there are concerns about her mental health?

Are you sure it isn't your hesitation over the stents that she sees as a betrayal?

The other question I have is about your status as decision-maker. Given that the doctor needs your consent to proceed with surgery, I take from that that you have MPOA, yes? In which case, no matter how upset with you she is for the moment, your mother can't actually refuse to have anything to do with you because you will still be the decision-maker; so like it or not she will be safe in your hands in that respect. Only, not speaking to you :(

What do you want to do next? Have you contacted the psychiatrist?
Sat2018 Jun 2022
She is seeing the hospital psychiatrist. They had to call them in when she lost it, fought the nurses and ran into the hallway swinging a metal rod. She thinks everyone is out to get her and are conspiring to make her look crazy, there is "nothing wrong" with her mind. They eavesdrop on her, spy on her and make up stories.

When I tried to talk to her about it on a more alert day after her first hospitalization she first tried to deny what I was saying, and then claimed she was being drugged if she did act that way.

I have requested to speak to the hospital psychiatrist treating her. I want to know if there is any chance of improvement via medication or if there would be a chance improving heart function would help.

Problem is unless she is deemed unsafe to live alone and made to go into some type of assisted living situation she will insist on going home which is a disaster waiting to happen. And now that I have been lumped in with the enemy she will refuse my help as well.

ADVERTISEMENT


Beatty Jun 2022
While it may have been polite to inform you that he was there with your Mother, not a lot can be done about that now.

Just go forward with honesty. Tell Mom a simple version of the truth.

Tell her the Doctor says she is very sick. That she needs a heart operation. That you are very concerned.

"I've been trying to do is what best".
Ask for her help.
Ask her wishes.
As in, have heart surgery or give over to mother nature.

Hard conversations are sometimes necessary.
Hopefully she understands.

Beatty Jun 2022
Re the Cardio Dr:
"pushy and wants me to give him a quick yes rather than give me time to make a decision which is in my mother's best interest, not his".

Wait. This IS reasonable. Wait until there is more stability, or at least until you get more facts & you have time to make a considered decision.

Your Mother has many health issues. The Dr is talking heart stent surgery here. Not treating a chest infection or UTI (sure start the usual anti until we get the labs back & swap to another anti if req'd).

Re: nursing home:
"rather lay in the floor and die" than go to a nursing home or assisted living.

If this is what she has ALWAYS said, consider the bases of it - she values 'independance' & 'quality of life' over 'longevity'.

However, if this is NEW, I'd guess it is probably fear based. (We all can be fearful of the unknown).

Trust your gut instinct. To act as your known Mother (pre-confused) would want. 🤗
You are doing wonderfully at being her avocate.
Sat2018 Jun 2022
Thank you. I've been up all night just a mess over this. I only want to do the right thing for her, even if she can no longer understand that.
KaleyBug Jun 2022
I feel your mom feels you gave up on her by denying her the stents. My mother in law had dementia and broke her hip at 96. We chose to do the surgery because she would never realize she had to stay in bed if we did not. We knew the risk at her age but she did fine and lived and walked with out any aids for over a year. If someone had not rear ended the car she was riding in she probably would of lived longer.

MarkMoore Jun 2022
Maybe the doctor thought your mom should hear the conversation. She's the patient.

RedVanAnnie Jun 2022
When people talk about Hospice Care they seem to imply that Hospice is a place a patient can be placed, perhaps for free. Although some Hospice Services have "facilities," most Hospice services are provided for the patient in the home with family or hired care givers doing the 24/7 care giving. The difference is that Hospice will supervise and provide comfort medications and send a nurse a couple of times a week to check vitals and order medicine. There will also often be a visit or two each week by an aide who can help with bathing and check on needed supplies.

Hospice does not take over care giving.

There may be Hospice companies or arrangements where a patient is actually physically placed in a care facility, but that is not the usual situation.
VegetaBohls Jun 2022
From the way that it sounds, she’s not ready for hospice care. Granted I don’t feel that a student given her mental abilities is the right thing to do especially since studies have shown they don’t typically extend a persons life. My mom has dementia that’s getting worse Parkinson’s disease a spot on her lungs and then a large day order Wes talking in her heart and the cardiologist said well you know we can manage may be some symptoms but at her age and health it’s really not conducive to do any type of procedures. However, as bad as it seems she’s not near the end of her life. Therefore, she’s not a candidate for hospice care.
Jasmina Jun 2022
If she has dementia she sure is smart enough to call you to vent. She knew exactly who to pick on to vent. Im sorry that happened to you. If your mom does that again, hang up. I'd say I'm not tolerating this abuse. Then hang up. Follow through. You are not her personal whipping post because her life is not good. You deserve not to be yelled at, or her taking things out on you. Or saying vile hurtful hateful things.
Perhaps in a day or 2, she will forget what she said. People with dementia say all sorts of vile and horrible things. It is deliberately aimed at loved ones, because a staff member will walk away. A staff member will them to stop. They won't tolerate it. Why should you??? You don't have to take being berated or abused. Do not tolerate it! You wouldn't tolerate a stranger or coworker berating you. Do not tolerate your mother doing it. She is lashing out because she is hating she is old, knows something is wrong with her mind, and doesn't like what is happening. You are the easy target. She gets a reaction.

Does your mom have an end of life care plan? Did she say she doesn't want heroic efforts to keep her alive? What is her quality of life now? Stuck in a bed? Does the doc say the stents will let her live so many more years? She has congestive heart failure so it's not going to stop the disease.
Id go by what her directives say. If you can't decide, ask him what would he do if that was his relative. If he said I would do it, then I would, and let the cards fall where they may. If you cant make the decision, let him. My mom had congestive heart failure. She never wanted to go to the doctors. But at the end of her life she wanted more time. She got stents. Most people want life.

I had a woman with dementia say very vile things to me. She was just put in the nursing home and was lashing out. I kept telling myself she has dementia but it still hurt. I finally went (grey rock) not answering, not saying anything, not reacting. She did not get the response she wanted and stopped. They want the reaction.

Do not take it personally even though that is very hard not to. If she yells at the doc, he will walk out of the room. You stayed on the phone and listened to her say nasty things to you. Stop doing that!
Would you take it from anyone else? No, you wouldnt. You dont have to be nasty, just say im not listening and hang up, or walk out of the room. It will stop. It won't until you stand up for yourself.
Do not keep thinking about what she said. Her mind is diseased.
Every time it pops into your head tell yourself you are doing your best and say it's the disease, then put it out of your head. Give your mom some no contact time. Pamper yourself, and do something for you, no matter how little. You are doing your best. You are a good daughter. You have done nothing wrong. You know that.
Don't see her until you feel better and are stronger. You know you are doing your best. Let it go.

Louise315 Jun 2022
It’s been a while since you posted, so I’m wondering how things went?

My father also suffered from anosognosia as a dementia patient. It’s very difficult for you as a caregiver - I’m sorry you have to go through this!

His dementia was always worse when hospitalized. Like your mother, he had arterial sclerosis as a Comorbidity, and probably suffered from vascular dementia, although we never had him formally assessed because he was so resistant to any suggestion of mental illness.

One of the things we did as a family was to offer him a choice. We had two assisted living places for him to choose from once he was discharged and in rehab. That really seemed to help as he at least felt like he had a part in the decision making process that way. For him, money was not an obstacle.

Prior to giving him the choice, he was very angry and unhappy. Once we found a good assisted living home - his choice - and tweaked his meds, he was much more content. It is such a burden for you to have to bear this on your own!

I was MPOA and he was moved from his current home closer to me during the end of his life, so I was his primary family caregiver. I found it so painful to have to deal with his resistance and anger. He passed two months ago while on hospice.

You are a loving and good daughter. You need to hear that because even though you rationalize and understand that mom is sick due to the dementia, it still scars you emotionally. You are already grieving the loss of the mother you knew.

Regarding the surgery, I’m curious about your mothers age? Dad could have had a procedure done to stretch the opening of his esophagus (he was having choking issues), but the doctor was very AGAINST doing the procedure because of his age at the time (90). We did discuss the procedure with him, and he took part in deciding not to have it done, although later I’m positive he had no recollection of the discussion.

I hope you are able to resolve this situation soon, and get mom into a good care environment. It’s so hard until you do! Dad bounced around from home care (with caregivers) to independent living with support, and finally to assisted living, once he was there, it was so much easier on me, as I could visit as family, and not have to do the physical part of the caregiving which he really resented.

One place I found tremendously helpful was the Teepa Snow website: Positive Approach to Care:
https://teepasnow.com/. I learned more from her and her team members about dementia care than I did from anyone or anything else.

Dad was also on hospice for a little over a year near the end, and they were amazing! Helped him get one last visit to his happy place (a lakehouse he owned) despite severe immobility and incontinence.

Hoping for a good resolution to your situation! Sending hugs, prayers, and positive thoughts your way: ❤️‍🩹🫂😔

AlvaDeer Jun 2022
This would be bound to come as a result of speaking around a patient and not TO the patient. I would simply tell Mom that you were trying to honor her by not putting her through something you feared might in fact KILL her while being treated. But that you had no idea she was hale and hearty enough to be listening in to every single word spoken. Apologize for yourself. Apologize for the doctor who apparently was under the same misapprehension, as HE was not talking to her but instead talking to her MPOA. Do understand that Mom's anger is also a result of her getting not quite enough or not quite normal levels of O2 to her brain.
The real message here is that MOM is still THERE and Mom wants to make her own decisions. Let her, would be my advise, and I wish you all the best.
You made an observation that the doctor wants her to have this to get her out of the hospital. Not true. The doctor will likely have to give her another day for this procedure. Otherwise, without it there is no reason at all for Mom to be in hospital; she doesn't need acute care, rather hospice if she is not getting treatment.
Go ahead with the treatment if Mom chooses. Without it her life is likely forfeit. With it she may have more time. Let her decide. I sure wish you the best. Nothing to do at this time but tell her you were mistaken in thinking she couldn't weigh in on her own decision and you apologize and hope she will forgive you and that you won't do it again.

See All Answers

ADVERTISEMENT

Ask a Question

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter