My husband (84) has been battling dementia/depression for the past three years. He has an annual mri and neuropsychological test to see the progression. We were forced to change neurologists recently . So this year , I asked the new neurologist if they could identify the type of dementia and perhaps what stage he was in . They ordered a PET scan that was specific to reading Alzheimer’s. ( after months of waiting)
I was so looking forward to the results of the PET scan and it came back that they didn’t show any Alzheimer’s or other dementia . This result blew my mind ! He has gotten so much worse with both dementia and depression . Now they want to do a spinal tap to see if he may have some underlying condition that has made his symptoms so much worse so quickly .
I’m so tired of all of these tests. My husband continues to get more depressed and confused . Do I put him through a spinal tap or just stop trying to figure out what stage he is in .
I don’t know whether we are going through unnecessary tests.
My mom’s doctor did put her on vitamin B.
It’s so interesting to track the importance that vitamins and supplements have in our bodies.
If it's a UTI, or vitamin deficiency, etc., those things can be treated, and he might be able to improve.
My mother is slipping into dementia. Several years ago, perhaps three, her neurologist began pressing for a spinal tap to check for Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus (NPH). My dad, who has since passed away, refused--he did not want her to go through the pain of it, and the shunt procedure that would be the result of finding NPH seemed, well, horrible. (An internal shunt is tucked in near the brain, draining the extra fluid through an internal tube that is run into the stomach. Yikes.) So they decided not to do it. Dad passed away a year ago, and mom began slipping much more quickly. We decided to go ahead with the spinal tap and pursue the shunt if needed.
The spinal tap was evidently not nearly as painful as we had been told. Mom did not complain about it at all after the fact. I was shocked. Then we did have the shunt procedure done--we didn't know what else to do, and decided to just go with what the doctors were telling us to do. It is just an overwhelming thing. They shaved half of her head, and there is an obvious tube under the skull. She was in intensive care for two days. But the recovery was fairly easy.
The doctor would not say whether we would see gains. He said that, because we had waited so long, he thought at best it would slow the progression of the dementia.
And this is important--he told us that the shunt would stop working after 18 months. And no, they do not ever take it out. So it seems that, in our case at least, we were only going to gain a year and a half, at best.
The outcome for us was about 6 months of gains. We are at about 6 months, and she has suddenly started slipping again. He walking is becoming problematic again. She is beginning to hear people singing outside here bedroom all night.
I'd like to mention that after my mom had her shunt surgery, we ran into ALL KINDS of people who had had this done--even a woman who was about 40. NPH is evidently more common than you'd think. It seems that if done early enough, there is a fairly good chance of it making a good difference. I am still confused about what I read about it--the articles make the shunt seem like a very long-term solution to draining the fluid, while our surgeon said that was not the case. Perhaps after the fluid is initially drained in some people, the problem resolves? I don't know, but do ask your doctor about this.
Would we do it again? Honestly, I don't know. We were initially excited about the gains, but it is looking like a short time of gains is all we will get. If I had known that in advance, I suspect we would not have done it.
NPH is idiopathic--they do not know what causes it. I read that one doctor suspects it might be a variation of Wernicke's Encephalopathy, one not caused by alcoholism. He suggested you work hard to correct any possible dietary and nutrient deficiencies and see what happens--especially the B vitamins. My mother's diet is not good--too much sugar, way too many carbs--but they would not comply with diet or supplement regimens I tried to encourage. The meals delivered sit uneaten in the freezer.
I know this might not be too much help, but wanted to share my story. If his dementia has not progressed too much, as my mom's had, you may get great results from a shunt--many people do. This is really the only form of dementia where there is a proven treatment that can be a game-changer.
Please read the NPH article in another reply. I will try to find it and put it here also. It has very good information. Best of luck!!
https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/15849-normal-pressure-hydrocephalus-nph
As I wrote beliw, the spinal tap did not seem to be as bad for my mom as people said it might be—new techniques? I don’t know. I was not in the room, and can only go by what my mom with moderate dementia told me; she did not seem traumatized by the procedure. Best wishes!