Follow
Share

Is there a link? Is there firm science behind it? Not just the same old "we think it's linked"


What is the person is just tired from other reasons? like having to go to the bathroom and that's why elderly are sleeping more?


I realize health care has improved over the decades, but I feel detection, getting to root cause is still in back to the 1800's. I'm not impressed with modern doctors, they only give medicines for the symptoms. Doctors these days, the local ones never seem to know what's wrong, they take all the vitals, and then say "I think you might have this" or "I think we should try this first" It's never a firm, you're getting these symptoms because the root cause is "X" and we have to treat "X" to make you better.


Yes procedures have improved, cures have not!


We should be at a stage where a doctor connects one wire or gets one drop of blood and the computer read out gives you the list of conditions you you currently have in an instant and the ones you are going to have in the future, so they can be averted.


Currently it's only the "big talk" that has advanced.


Did anyone detected a hint of frustration?

The human mind/brain is way too complicated an organ to ever completely understand entirely, imo. It would be nice if after 10 years or so of limited training, doctors could be God and know everything, but that's unrealistic, coming from a person who's been suffering constant vertigo for over 17 months now along with an eye condition in both eyes after immunotherapy that nobody has an answer for. Yeah, it's very frustrating indeed.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
oldageisnotfun2 Jul 14, 2024
Hi Lealonnie1, I feel for your situation it is frustrating.

Provided no global geopolitical event does not get in the way. If they put AI to work, which can out do humans a billion fold we'll start seeing revolutionary changes in medicine. All that money funding wars should be going into things like AI to advance medicine instead. Bio-tech and AI is going to change things quickly, if they let it.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
As already said , huge strides have been made in medicine . That being said a lot of those strides have been discovered through trial and error .

Medical treatment is always evolving . For example when I was in college to be a nurse it was thought that Crohn’s disease was caused by stress , anxiety , a mental health problem causing the symptoms . Only 20 years later when my own teenage son was diagnosed with it they had discovered it was an autoimmune disease .

The human body is complex and there is still alot of unknowns . For example they still don’t know what triggers a pregnant woman to go into labor .

They have made great strides in cancer and like already said immunizations and antibiotics saved so many children’s lives .

Aging people is a different story . The aging body is like an old car , it is just being propped up . To expect cures for what ails the aging body such as heart disease , dementia , kidney disease etc . Is asking for a miracle . My in laws were like that . They thought medicine would have them feeling like they were 40 forever and just drop dead one day .

As far as the doctors not being able to pin down exactly what’s wrong in the aging person……well , so many problems have similar symptoms . So it’s not always clear what is the cause . When an aging person has many chronic issues they also play off one another. Heart disease causes lung problems and Vice versa . Diabetes causes kidney disease , heart disease , strokes . High blood pressure , high cholesterol causes , heart disease. strokes, dementia , kidney disease . Etc .

The aging body is much more difficult to manage than a healthy young person that needs an antibiotic to cure strep throat .

All kinds of strange reasons were “ thought “ to cause certain diseases back in the old times until research was done , discoveries made , leading to effective cures and treatments . And people who still believed the crazy reasons and crazy ineffective cures had to be convinced that the “ modern cures “ weren’t witch craft .

The “ we think it’s linked” as you described is a normal part of discovery during learning about a disease . There will never be a cure for dementia because like heart disease it’s a problem of the body aging .

A friend of mine who was a doctor used to say that “ Doctor’s “ practice “ to try to get it right . They don’t know everything about how the human body works and are always learning “. He was an ER doctor and this was what he said about his frustration over patients expecting him to be able to always pin down exactly what was wrong .
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to waytomisery
Report

"We should be at a stage where a doctor connects one wire or gets one drop of blood and the computer read out gives you the list of conditions you you currently have in an instant and the ones you are going to have in the future, so they can be averted"

Star Trek territory you mean? We have made so many huge strides in healthcare over the last century, consider that during the first world war people died of sepsis because antibiotics were only rudimentary science and children died every day from diseases easily prevented by vaccination, that may seem like ancient history to some but given that my parents were born in 1919/1920 it's all still part of living history.

As for the sleeping - being older is tiring, I'm only in my 60's and I already notice how much more effort it takes to do things that I once did effortlessly without even noticing. Plus it's a rare octogenarian who doesn't have at least one chronic health condition which puts a strain on the body.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to cwillie
Report

Is your question, "Why do people with dementia sleep more?"

or is it

"Is poor sleep quality correlated to developing dementia?"

They are 2 different things.

I think this should be moved to Discussions...
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
oldageisnotfun2 Jul 13, 2024
It's true what you say about planet using up more resources if there was reversed aging and living longer, but It can be controlled from the other end too, i.e. new births.

If people want that option to live longer it shouldn't be denied, it's like saying you can't have the medicine because it will extend your life.

If people are saying eating fruits and veg to living longer is natural way to live longer, but most raw foods is grown using man made fertilizer which can be considered unnatural. human have interfered with almost everything to make it unnatural. People in these various fields of work have gone to far down the road of science and technology already and they're not about to make any U-turns at this stage.

Rephrased question: Is a change in sleeping habits, i.e. sleeping more, waking up later during the day a sign, symptom of dementia? without any other type of sleep disruption.

It's a question and a discussion. Where should it be moved. Needhelpwithmom.. has also previously mentioned it makes little difference if it's in Discussions, discussions fizzle out really quickly on this forum.

I prefer no rigid boundaries of where things are kept, just open talk, how it should be.
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
My BIL is a Dr of immuniology. He started his career in 1980 researching catfish for their immune systems, seems they are like humans. If they could find the immortal cell, they could cure all autoimmune deseases. They found the immortal cell about 25 years after he got involved with the research. It was a fluke so needed to figure out how they did it. He worked another 5yrs before he retired. Had not been able to replicate the findings.

Research takes a long time. When your talking Dementia your talking about the brain which we are still trying to find out how it works. Everyone's Dementia journey is different. Some brought it on themselves. Over use of alchohol. Smoking. Not taking care of themselves. Heredity which Alzhemier's is. So Drs are still guessing. There are basic stuff but the brain is complex.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
Fawnby Jul 13, 2024
Occupation-related dementia: football players, boxing pros, jet pilot in armed services. Yet dementia is the last thing people think of when they sign on to those jobs. They are not warned of dementia as possible result.
(2)
Report
If People are Ill they need rest and sleep to heal . With Dementia people Its best to let them sleep - a Nap , same bed time , a routine .
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to KNance72
Report
oldageisnotfun2 Jul 13, 2024
I agree with this reply. thank you.
(1)
Report
I believe getting good sleep is one of the pillars of dementia health. However each specialist prescribes to what they can only do in their scope of practice. You will have to ask a geriatric specialist about correlation because there is some data out there but I am not about to do that research for you. Most of it has to do with preventing or slowing onset of dementia and not useful when someone is in the thick of it. Data is most important to the specialist.

Sleep studies are part of my specialty. However for patients with dementia, even if they were prescribed a sleep apnea machine they would pull it off withing 5 minutes because their brains are broken and they cannot comprehend what it is needed for.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MACinCT
Report
oldageisnotfun2 Jul 15, 2024
Thank you. yeah this is very frightening to people thinking about old age and what might happen to them. Many have talked about the complexity of the brain and body in reply to this post. I agree with their view on it.

I only discovered what Sleep Apnea is today, because you mentioned it. I didn't know about this disorder, but they say it causes sleep disruption and you're right this could be another reason for sleeping longer as well as needing to go to the toilet during the night. As you mentioned I'll do some reading and research.

Some times I feel what's the point there's 100s of conditions people can get during old age, many get before old age, but most would agree more health problems of all types start creeping in one by one, slowly taking away something we once took for granted. Is that all there is to it, life? born, grow up, probably have a partner, probably have children, grow old, get various health problems and then die, and many thinking there's something more afterwards.

Sometimes I think what is life for, all these 8 billion plus people doing the same things, where's it all heading? why are we here? what does it mean to living? if it's for joy why is there so much pain?
(0)
Report
Thank you for the replies, I do appreciate the opposing views as well.

Don't forget yesterday's sci-fi is today's reality.

It might be a bit like Star Trek, but sci-fi sets the targets, the goals to achieve. No one knew Artificial Intelligence (AI) was going to take off so quickly but it has, still very early stages but, AI was considered Star Trekky not long ago.

The talk (hype) about the Medical breakthroughs far outweigh the reality and this is where my frustration come in. News report: Doctor's in US have discovered such and such, but will be 20 years before it is useful to anyone. Why not just inform us when it's actually useful to humans from day one of the announcement, not give people the hope and then say it will be 20 years before it becomes useful.

I stand by my views, advancement is way too slow and talk is hyped up too much. The quicker they get AI on to it the better, this is one good use for AI. million times faster than humans. Liz Homes may have fooled people with your claims about blood testing, but there will be a time when one drop of blood tells you all, or even without the drop of blood, just a 30 second full body scan. It's around this decade we should already have these things.

https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2024-07-09/artificial-intelligence-medicine-diagnosis

I want to see certain areas advance a million fold from where it is today and medicine is one of them.

I want to see reversal of all conditions, decalcification of Aortic Value with only medicine. Reversal of any cognitive impairment with medicine, Reversal of aging itself down to a certain selected adult age, for instance 25 years old.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to oldageisnotfun2
Report
waytomisery Jul 13, 2024
In general this country is slow to FDA approve many things . Partially because we live in such a litigious society . Society does also effect progress of many things .

Also money is a factor . Don’t know if this is true or not , but have heard that the common cold can be eradicated by vaccine ( like polio in this country ) . Have read two different reasons why it hasn’t been .

The first being that drug companies won’t allow it do to the amount of money they make on cold medicines .

The second ( and I read this long before Covid happened ) , that there was a fear it would open the door to a much more deadly virus . The theory being that plentiful less dangerous viruses help crowd out other new mutants .

I think doctors are also frustrated and think research could be faster . They have little control over that . It comes down to big Pharma , and funding for research , insurance companies , government entities etc .

That being said , I still think it’s impressive how far medicine has come in the past 100 years compared to centuries of no progress .
(2)
Report
See 3 more replies
Living longer has huge implications for life on earth: living space from crowding, the need to develop lab-based (not land-based) food, increased need of natural resources, the cost burden. It will be less Star Trek-y and more Solient Green-ish...

And honestly, after experiencing how nasty people are even on a forum like this...who wants to spend more time with an world filled with THOSE people? Yech.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
oldageisnotfun2 Jul 13, 2024
Definitely agree with you about the people aspect, so very true. There was question from Ventingisback a while ago about which things annoy you most about other people. There was no shortage of replies on that one...

I kept joking with Venting...about reaching 99.99% of the people yet.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Hi everyone. I just found out this information on the sleep and dementia. It's in this link: https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/blog/is-it-typical-people-dementia-sleep-lot-during-day.

especially this part of the post: "If the person is in the later stages of dementia and they have gradually started sleeping more and more, it is likely to be due to the dementia progressing. "

So looking like if different stages are early, middle and late. If in early or middle stages the long sleep into the day could be related to something else, however in early or middle stages, it might still be a sign that gradually longer sleep is tied to early stage dementia at first, then middle stage, sleeping even longer, and in late stage sleeping even longer. It's definitely something to be watchful as a caregiver.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to oldageisnotfun2
Report

See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter