Follow
Share

I was POA over my father for 4 years. It's been 2 yrs since he’s been in nursing home. My family voted me out via a healthcare proxy. The sibling here in Florida is taking over, and he doesn’t do anything about the care my father is receiving.


He’s aware the facility is not doing what they’re supposed to do, yet he allows it. The facility would rather have him in charge because he doesn’t place concerns or grievances. I’ve witnessed my father with injuries, sitting in his own urine, feces, not provided basic hygiene care, g tube not attended to, other residents doing things to him, etc. He got very ill due to the facility not containing the COVID germs, and he ended up in the hospital and almost died due to pneumonia. I could go on.


Family members who were not involved nor provided any support became angry at me, stating I didn’t communicate with them, but I’m the one providing for all his needs as they continued on with their lavish lives. Once he became near death, they all want to fly in and blame me when it was the progression of his illness. They voted and overrode my decision to place him on a g-tube against his will in the paperwork I have.


In a nutshell, they have taken over out of spite and are preventing the nursing home and the other providers from communicating with me. Can the healthcare proxy do this?

Find Care & Housing
I think this family needs family therapy and elder care mediation to get on board for everyone respecting and following your dad’s wishes. It is not unlikely that he now lacks cognitive capacity to change his documents. And FYI, GI feeding tubes make the body less comfortable, NOT more comfortable. Many patients try to pull them out even when unconscious. If none of these ideas work for you or for the family, then find a highly experienced Elder law attorney. Www.NAELA.org lists members by location. A certified elder law attorney is the most experienced and has passed the most tests. You can also google Adult Guardianship mediation. Adult children fighting over elder care of their parents is one of the most vicious of battles. If you live in CA, you can contact CA Advocates for Nursing Home Reform for referral in your own county or just discuss the matter with a CANHR advocate. . But if your dad is in Florida, you will need a really good experienced elder law attorney in Florida. Wishing your dad the ability to live out the rest of his life as he intended, and for all of the adult children to support him in that. Each one needs to face the fact that your dad is on his way out this life of his, and what is most needs is peace and love from all of his kids, not one more than the other.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to ElderCareAtty
Report

How did your family get healthcare proxy? Your father would have had to assign someone to make decisions on his behalf. If he was unable, or did not, then they would have had to go to court and make a compelling case to get healthcare proxy or to revoke your POA.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

This is where you can file complaints about the substandard care:

https://ahca.myflorida.com/contact-ahca/file-a-complaint
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to MG8522
Report

Chardonae: Retain an attorney.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report

Regular POAs have decisionmaking over finances and healthcare proxies over medical matters. These forums sometimes use the terms interchangeably but they are not. Is your dad competent? Just because he is in a nursing home doesn't mean he's not competent. He is the one who would appoint a new healthcare proxy. No one else has the ability to do that except a judge.
But do you mean that you were the POA and someone else was the healthcare proxy all along? Many families do this. Then you are kind of stuck and should see an attorney about challenging it. Of course you can always report the facility for negligence.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Jennyjenjen
Report
Chardonae Feb 16, 2025
I have reported it. When they came out Dad had supposedly had scabies from the facility. I feel the agent was afraid to evaluate him out of fear of catching the scabies. I offered him many photos to confirm my case, but he declined and said Dad looked fine and closed the case.
(0)
Report
If you have/had valid Power of Attorney assigned to you by your father, your family cannot "vote you out." You need to consult an Elder Law attorney.

Are you saying that you have financial POA, and a different family member had Health POA?

If there is paperwork that your father did not want a G-tube, did/does the nursing home have that paperwork?

Regardless of who has the authority, if the nursing home has been providing substandard and negligent care, you can report them to whatever state agency has oversight of them.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to MG8522
Report
Chardonae Feb 16, 2025
Yes I had POA over him since 2020. The siblings cause interference which cause the facilities Pace to questioned my POA which they accepted for a year before the siblings came to visit. The Pace had a meeting and decided to do a healthcare proxy and not continue to accept my paperwork saying they couldn’t accepted it no longer it wasn’t legit since it was done in California and he now resides in Florida. The family did a vote upon they’d request and of course voted me out and appointed the only other sibling that lives here. The sibling that lives here has stopped all communication to me meaning he informed the facilities PACE & the nursing to not provide me any information or communicate with me. It’s disheartening as I was the only one who took care of all my Dads affairs since he came here without any help from the 5 siblings.
I attended his appointments, the meetings on his behalf and had him until it became too much for me. When he started leaving the home while a care attendant was in place while I worked out of fear he’d get lost or hurt I had to place him in assisted living not a nursing home.
Assisted living I felt it would still allow him some independence were he felt like he still was in control. It worked for awhile, but the disease started progressing he stopped eating and list a lot of weight and was placed in another facility due to neglect from that facility and placed on a nursing home.
(0)
Report
Can you clarify your statement about ...they voted and overruled my decision to place a g-tube against your dads will in paperwork...did you have it placed or did they?

Whomever did this should NOT be in charge. We make these wishes known in writing, when of sound mind, to stop someone else from making these decisions on our behalf. If they did it, you should pursue guardianship, if you did it, sorry but, I fully understand them stepping in and pushing you out.

May The Lord be with your dad and your family. It is unfortunately very common for family feuds to break out over an end of life situation.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Isthisrealyreal
Report
Chardonae Feb 16, 2025
As I stated before. I was appointed POA years ago when he resided in California. He’s now in Florida due to the siblings sending him here due to one sibling flew on took him to reside with him, but changed his mind and had the sibling that lives where I reside pick him up and drive him to me. I stated in a video meeting months before if the siblings were going to take him from his home (due to he was being evicted) I would take him to prevent more trauma by then placing him in a Nursing home which at that time his condition wasn’t as bad he could walk, talk, do something for himself.
none of the siblings wanted to take him in they all had bigger homes and more lavish lifestyle than myself. I’m the only one who said I would take him. My Father stated he didn’t want to be on a feeding tube which was in the paperwork. He signed off on a DNR. He verbally told me he didn’t want to be in a Nursing home if he was dying he wanted to be in his own home which he doesn’t have. I would love to have him with me with help, but unfortunately my townhouse is inadequate for him and it’s too small.
The Healthcare proxy came in because the siblings who don’t reside here and the one that does argued the credibility of the POA which made PACE Partners (resource for the elderly) question my paperwork that they already had for over a year and was honoring it until the siblings brought trouble.
I was honoring my Fathers request. They are not. I tried to get him hospice at the Nursing home which he would receive more eyes on him when they didn’t do their job, but the siblings didn’t want that. PACE had a meeting in which their was a vote as well as the Nursing home and the siblings voted me out and for the only other sibling other than myself that resides in the state my Dad is in to be Healthcare proxy.
My Dads condition has worsened.
The Nursing home neglects his needs everytime I visit I see things aren’t appropriate. I have brought the attention to the one with the control yet he doesn’t believe me even when I provide photos. He has now informed the facilities to not communicate with me or provide me information. My Fathers care is worsening which means he’s suffering even more. This has caused me major stress which has caused my own autoimmune issues to flare because I feel powerless! I told him I would always be there for him as he did for me. I have been advocating for him since he’s been here and now no one will listen. I came to this forum for advice not to be continued gained up on or judged harshly. I can get that from 5 other siblings would are upset due to their own bad conscious because they didn’t support nor wanted him in their home. When he lived with me none of them offered support, asked if we needed anything or even just called me. Even if we agreed to disagree he is all our Father and it should have been about him not us.
I felt since I’m the only one who took him in at least they could of supported me and asked me if their was anything they could go to help or if I needed a break, but instead when they thought he was dead due to false information given to them by his ex wife they all flew in and berated, disrespected me. They were not educated on his disease and how it progressed. I did the best I could as I’ve never dealt with anything like this all the while trying to maintain my home, my own illness which was under control until they brought all the turmoil. I could go on but it’s pointless and it only stresses me more to think or talk about it. My Father deserves so much more. He raised us 6 and later help raise 5 more kids. He always worked. He did the best he could. He is a good man. It troubles me to see he suffer and deteriorate even faster due to he’s not getting the care he needs. I’m sicken because I feel I’m not heard and now no one will listen. I feel like I’m dying with him sometimes.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
You say this:
"I was POA over my father for 4 years. It's been 2 yrs since he’s been in nursing home. My family voted me out via a healthcare proxy. The sibling here in Florida is taking over, and he doesn’t do anything about the care my father is receiving."

Because, to me, this makes utter ZERO sense, I am afraid I can't answer for the legalities; there are too many pieces MISSING in your telling. I will refer you to an attorney of your choice for answers.
#1. No health care proxy has any ability to "vote you out". You cannot be removed as POA by anyone but the competent person who conferred it upon you or by a judge of the courts.
#2. No sibling "takes over POA" any other way but a competent parent appointing him as POA.

You next proceed to inform us:
"They voted and overrode my decision to place him on a g-tube against his will in the paperwork I have."
I have a bit of a hard time understanding this statement, but if the rest of the family knew he didn't want a G-tube, and that was in his directive (it sure is in MY OWN) and you overrode this wish of his, then shame on you, and thank goodness for his family coming in to have his wishes honored. YOU violated your POA if he had written he didn't want a g-tube. The POA acts FOR someone and IN ACCORDANCE with his wishes.

To be honest here, just on the face of what is written and assuring you that I think this was likely done LEGALLY and for the BEST by his family, I side with them in allowing this poor gentleman the peaceful death he wished for. I hope they have Hospice care in for him. He cannot take sustenance any longer and is in care; the trajectory is downward and living like this is, in the opinion of this retired RN, a torture.

I do not know what legal rights the family has brought in to act in your dad's behalf; I can only say I am glad they have done so. You have every right to seek legal representation in your own state; that wouldn't be us. We are just caregivers and ex-caregivers with an opinion. I wish you peace.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

Similar to my story. My older sister and my oldest had access to my mom’s finances and they we’re not, in my opinion, taking proper care of her. My mom was diagnosed with cognitive impairment and was unable to care for herself. After several visits to her PCP and stays in rehab (was found on the bathroom floor) I retained a lawyer and became her guardian. If they were to continue, unchecked, she would have ended up in a nursing home and would be dead by now. My mom now lives in an assisted living facility with a memory care unit (pricey but all inclusive) and she is doing great. Nonetheless, I am still fighting with them to sell some of her property to help pay for her stay. Months before she was diagnosised they took her to a lawyer to add MY oldest son’s name to the deed to the house and changed it to a life estate were we all have to agree to sell it and all of us would receive 1/6 of the proceeds (my mom, her 4 children, and my son) which leaves nothing for HER care. Myself and my other 2 siblings have already signed over our interest to her. In the end, in this case, its all about the money. When property and money are added to mix, its your own family that will do you in, GREED SHOWS ITS UGLY FACE! I pray it all works out for you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Alonwithcmpany
Report

My opinion, you need a lawyer. If your POAs were valid and invoked no one but your Dad can assign a new POA. I always recommend a lawyer when getting a POA done. They will take the principle aside and make sure the are not being coerced and are competent to assign a POA. If a POA is immediate, its invoked as soon as the principle signs the paper work. Springing mean a doctor or doctors have to sign off that a person is incompetent for the POAs to be invoked. If this was done and Dad was incompetent at time family says they got new POAs, then you need to question the new POAs. They may not be valid.

Anyone holding a Financial or Medical POA are not oblidged to give anyone information concerning the principle finances. Medical, just you and the doctors.
You are the principles representative and as such give out no info.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

To clarify, your Father is the one who legally would have assigned the new PoA. You can contest this if you think he was coerced, or if wasn't of sound mind when he did it.

If you are the active PoA then you need to call that facility and demand to know why they are ignoring your legally assigned status as your Father's MPoA. Your family voted to place him? They never had this power, you had all the power. But they weren't interested in participating in his care, so unless you wanted to be all by yourself doing it, then leave him in the facility.

If you're not the FPoA, who is? You need to play nice with this person.

If you're not the current MPoA, then yes, the new one (if legally assigned) can block you if they think you are creating a stress or chaos in the situation that negatively impacts your Father's care and wellbeing. You can consult with a certified elder law attorney to sort through what your options are, since you seem unsure of the PoA issue and who does and does not have it.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter