Follow
Share

On Christmas morning, my mom (79) was rushed to the hospital after having a severe left brain stroke impacting her right side. She lost speech and her arm and leg movement (arm is coming back somewhat). She was in the hosptial for 3 weeks due to atrial fibrulation (they think that was the cause of the stroke) and was finally released to rehab last Saturday.


This past Friday, when being dressed for the day, she accidentally pulled out her peg tube. We spent the entire weekend in the emergency room awaiting our options. This morning the interventional radiologist team attempted unsuccessfully to replace it. The current plan is to wait a week to ten days and attempt it again. The other option was surgery to remove and replace it... but they don't believe she is strong enough for this currently.


My question is, what are the options from here? I am second-guessing my decisions to support this course of action. I am her POA. She has a DNI and a DNR... but I don't have anything regarding feeding directives. She can swallow a bit, but does not seem interested in food. Puree is what she is able to have so I get most of it is gross, but even pudding or ice cream doesn't tempt her.


This has been devastating to her, and of course the family. I made the mistake of Googling the prognosis on a feeding tube. Am I delaying the inevitable? We lost our rehab placement becuase she is now back in the hospital.


I am hopeful she can return there when ready. It's been a month and she hasn't had a shot at rehab due to all these other issues. I would be grateful for any thoughts or options I might consider as I navigate this challenging time.

Find Care & Housing
If the pureed food is gross why not try some that isn't? Your mother might go for some nice real mashed potatoes gravy or some real fruit puree. My parent was the same way from a stroke. He would not eat the nasty pureed food the nursing home was pushing. When we brought good food, he ate. He liked the chocolate Ensure shakes too. Maybe yout mother is like my father was.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report

From a hospital nurse perspective:
1 - Have a temporary feeding tube placed down her nose into her stomach. A Dobhoff tube is thin, very flexible, and well-tolerated. With a nasogastric tube, she can receive medication, liquid food, and fluids that she needs to survive. This will work in the hospital until she is strong enough for other options.
2 - Let the interventional radiologist be the "lead" on how to get a gastric tube placed. He or she is a specialty doctor that can perform surgical-style procedures using radiology to guide placement. Whether he/she can go through the "original hole" or need to place a "new hole", let their advice guide you.
3 - Your mom can be placed on anticoagulation medication until she can have her new tube placed. With most short term anti-coagulation medications in the hospital, she would only need to be off them for a day at most before the procedure. After she heals a bit, she can be restarted on anticoagulation medication that can be used a rehab or long term care facility.
4 - Ask to speak with social worker or case manager about your mom's placement after the hospital. Hopefully, there will be space for her in the rehab facility she just left. If not, the case manager can help with placement in other facility that meets her needs with her insurance.
5 - Talk with doctor about your mom's DNR/DNI status. She can be a DNR/DNI in the hospital. Talk with the doctor about what options are available and get that implemented in her care. Sometimes, the doctor may get a referral to palliative care to help you with understanding all the options available as well as actually writing the order once you have made your decisions.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Taarna
Report

Unfortunately, most people must go on Medicaid for long term care when their funds run out since assisted living and nursing home costs are very exorbitant . Anyone fortunate with millions of dollars able to self-pay are fortunate to spare the government’s pay for long-term care in better circumstances than some understaffed facilities.

For myself, I requested no feeding tubes or other drastic life prolonging types on my health directive after 24 hours, so let me die to stop further suffering.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Patathome01
Report

My Mom had a stroke almost 5 years ago at 85 and was also on a feeding tube for a period of time. We have been through hell and back since then. It us a rough road ahead and although I cannot tell you what to do I can share that if I had to do it all over again with my Mom, I would have had her on hospice care right away. Life after a major stroke is never the same for that person. Everyone is different of course but in my Mom's case, she can't ever be alone due to cognitive decline, has very limited use of her right side and speech is spotty. This is after 5 years of pt, it and speech therapy. In and out of hospitals, rehab and seizures, falls and multiple uti's. Life is never the same for them and I hate to paint such a dark picture but I'm just wish someone would have told me years ago. I hope all works out for you and your family.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Surviving
Report
ElizabethAR37 Feb 2, 2025
I don't think this is a "dark" picture so much as it is a REALISTIC one, at least it would be as I see it. I would not want to have been mom in this case, but hindsight is 20/20. I hope I have prepared sufficient instructions as to my wishes before the fact.
(4)
Report
I agree with Fawnby and many others here. I am 76 and just fine right now, but if this happened to me, and no meaningful recovery could happen, I would want my kids to let me go. They know this. Comfort care only, nothing to prolong life. My best to you and your mom.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to ForWhatItsWorth
Report

I don't think it was a mistake googling prognosis on a feeding tube.
You want to be as well informed as you can be.
Perhaps get a second or third medical opinion.

Is your mom in pain? If so, does medical provider give her something for this?

I do not know if anyone can tell you if you are 'delaying the inevitable' in terms of decision making. These are difficult circumstances / decisions to be made. Everyone is different in their values, spiritual beliefs. You need to do what is best for your mom.

If it were my mom and she was coherent, I would take her lead - honor her wishes.

Are you religious?
Do you have a paster / spiritual guide / leader?
You could also ask to speak to the spiritual leaders at the hospital.
Perhaps not for answers, but for support.

Should this tube be replaced, insure that it can't be touched in ways where your mom can pull it out. I am a bit surprised that it wasn't more secure to begin with although I do not know how these things work.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to TouchMatters
Report

I know it’s a terrible thought I have. Animals can be euthanized so they suffer no further with their extreme medical conditions. I wish the same could be done for people suffering with no hope of recovery when comfort is insufficient.

It will save billions of taxpayer dollars to use for healthy seniors.

One document to set up is the POLST order to stop life saving machines that prolong life with no hope of recovery.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Patathome01
Report
swmckeown76 Feb 1, 2025
This isn't possible in the USA because the Supreme Court ruled a number of years ago that the US Constitution doesn't contain a fundamental right to assisted suicide. About 10 states and Washington, DC do allow it, though. Two of these states don't have residency requirements (think Oregon is one of them). Otherwise, the person requesting physician-assisted suicide (or nurse practitioner-assisted suicide in a couple of states) must be a state resident for at least 6 months, be able to swallow the lethal dose of medicine, and be competent at the time of ingesting the lethal dose to give final consent. Two practitioners must confirm that the individual has 6 months or less to live. There are also generally conscience rights: no physician or nurse practitioner can be forced into participating in an assisted suicide, and no hospital, clinic, nursing home, or assisted living center can be forced into allowing it on their premises. I'm truly sorry that you believe it would be a good idea to have people die prematurely because of all the money it would save. Yes, POLST (or MOLST) orders can limit medical treatment, but they aren't just given out like candy. A person has to usually have a life-limiting illness and she or he can rescind it at any time. BTW, my late husband and I spent about $500K on his nursing home care over 6 years, 4 months due to frontotemporal degeneration (he did have traditional Medicare and a Medicare supplement) and was never on Medicaid. So he really didn't cost the taxpayers much money at all, and I don't resent one cent of the money we spent on his care. And I would never authorize a DNR, DNI, or any restrictions on my health care, regardless of any future disease or disability.
(1)
Report
Perish forbid! At 88 I hope that I have left adequate instructions in writing so that I DO NOT end up being trapped in "existence" when I am longer "living". (If all else fails, my comments in this Forum should leave an unmistakable electronic trail of my wishes/feelings in this regard.)
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to ElizabethAR37
Report

Strokedaughter: Prayers sent.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report

Just a follow on re my wife (her preferred name is Sandi). She has plenty of care givers, including 24/7 Monica and while she is a functional quadriplegic, she is able to stretch, move her right arm, smile occasionally, listens to conversations, has vital signs that are good and is a believer in the power of Christ.

Last week one of the caregivers and me noticed she had a wry smile about some goofy comment I made and said that "I bet you live for that moment"!

I replied I did and give thanks to God for those moments and continue along with perhaps 40 other people daily pray for a miracle. I do have a palliative care nurse who visits every other week and we have had surgeries to address issues. My experience with PEG tube replacement is it is a 15 minute procedure, but does require anesthesia.

Bottom line, I would not recommend listening to too many others, but rather stay in communication with your loved one, such as it may be, pray, take steps to relieve pain and hope for a miracle and trust in God and keep your family involved, visiting and spiritually helping.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to GreystoneBill
Report

Just adding my situation with my mother in law in the 1990s. She had Alzheimers disease. When she was unable to eat without aspirating, my husband couldn't bear the thought of "starving her to death". We weren't told anything about how the body shuts down. Hospice was not offered by the nursing home doctor or social worker. My husband, as POA, had a feeding tube placed in her. She lingered in bed unaware of anything but pain for at least 2 years. Cancer finally took her life. It was dreadful.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to JanPeck123
Report
Suzy23 Jan 31, 2025
What a nightmare. Reading this makes me so glad I was able to and did choose hospice for my dad, and that I advocated against anything but palliative measures when he started having trouble swallowing. He got aspiration pneumonia and died two days later in hospice facility with morphine every two hours.

I am sorry she and you all had to go through that.
(6)
Report
See 1 more reply
Talk to a Hospice nurse. They can help with understanding the process AND help family members go from "oh no!" to "Ok, let's breath and say goodbye".
I just said goodbye to my mom and had the tough conversation with my dad to say goodbye. He was a trooper and did it all on his own. He is the one with the stroke, she had other issues including memory and passed 16 Jan. Hospice was the best in explaining / confirming what were were seeing. Not wanting to eat is one of those items.
God bless you and if you can get any contact with your mother, she can "talk" to you with eyes, with gestures. As POA your job is to respect her wishes, not second guess everyone else. I went so far as to remind my mother of a "lingering" conversation we had even six months ago - time to fight to get out of bed and get breakfast with your husband, or go see your Dad (one consist memory that she repeated). My mom was not communicative, but when I said "I need you to listen" her "no, no, no,.." stopped. She heard me and the reminder of the conversation.
YOU know your mom. TRUST that!
SO grateful for this forum!
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to RainbowHeart
Report
MiaMoor Feb 2, 2025
I'm so sorry for your loss.
Be kind to yourself while you grieve.
(2)
Report
Despite witnessing similar sad times with my mother, I'm still pretty "lay" with medical terms and newer medical options, but here's my story anyway. At 66 Mom turned around her 1st stroke about 70% through time and rehab. Her speech was mostly affected, along with some cognitive abilities. She never could drive or work again after that. She had another small stroke (A-fib related) a couple yrs later, but the 3rd one when she was 79 was way worse than your Mom's. The 3rd one resulted in Mom's loss of any means of communicating and her ability to swallow while she lay just following us around her hospital bed with her eyes. She also contracted pneumonia from aspirating initial feeding attempts by nurses.

Mom had no formal directives for her care, so we listened to the advice of her physician. The plan was to take her off all meds for severe pneumonia and transport her to nursing facility to die quickly and peacefully. Her death was anything BUT!!! My brother and I and a nurse's aide gruesomely watched 4 to 5 hours of Mom gasping for breath, sitting up in her bed with fear and agony until she finally collapsed and died from exhaustion and drowning in the fluids in her lungs. I tell you this because your Mom sounds like she's medically somewhere in-between my Mom's 1st and 3 stroke. Your mom still has her cognitive abilities but will need long-term car for many physical needs and food nourishment. That may be quality of life enough for her, especially if the feeding tube can be used successfully again.

Based on our and our mom's horrendous outcome, I wouldn't be too abrupt to throw in the towel, and perhaps instead consider the reinsertion of the feeding tube. Starving or drowning in your own bodily fluids IS NOT A HUMANE WAY TO DIE. If there are no other options for her to go on with some acceptable quality of life left, then definitely bring hospice services into the picture....they at least have some sense of humanity. Do not assume people/professionals who encourage you to not seek further medical attention for your mother are giving you the full picture of what to expect. To this day I have nightmares over the way I agreed to let my mom die! She deserved so much more dignity!
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Jannycare
Report
Lovemom1941 Jan 31, 2025
I am appalled at how you and your mom were treated. Hospice would have made her departure far more peaceful because they deal only in pain and relief of it. I am sorry for the trauma you and your family suffered. When my father-in-law could no longer swallow food, hospice came in and handled it beautifully. There was no suffering, just peace.
(6)
Report
See 2 more replies
As everyone has said, it's a difficult spot to be in. I feel like I should have something to say to you, since about 18 months ago I was in almost exactly your situation. I don't know if I have much useful advice, though. I can only tell you a bit about what I experienced. My dad, at 79, also had a large, serious stroke with similar effects. Because he was having some trouble swallowing during the first week, a feeding tube was placed. There were times over the next month that I asked about having it removed, since it had not yet actually been used. That ended up being a mistake, because the time came when he needed it. He pulled it out three or four times over the next year. I'll never know if it was accidental or purposeful. The hospital reinserted it each time.

Although he initially seemed to be improving a bit in rehab, dad never regained the ability to walk or talk. After several months he began to have serious problems with edema from his preexisting congestive heart failure. Just over a year after the stroke, he got COVID-19, developed a systemic infection probably from ulcers on his legs, and passed away four weeks later. Although his advanced directive did not include DNR or DNI instructions, during those last 10 days or so it was obvious we were near the end, and it fell to me as one with medical POA to sign DNR and DNI forms and start what they called "comfort" care. Regardless of what he had put in his advanced directive 30 years ago, I know he didn't want to continue "living" like he was.

From my experiences, I think a key thing for someone after such a stroke is if they are able to really succeed in rehab. Whether it was damage from the stroke, memory loss from dementia (already a problem for dad before the stroke), or just a lack of will, I think he just wasn't able to "do" rehab.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to CSX321
Report

I agree 100%with Bulldog54321. They do not have any “skin in the game “ and they deal with situations like yours every day.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Doubletrouble65
Report

I also commend you on reaching out, that for many is tough to do. You are in a tough spot. I am certain.
Like others, the directives in place say a lot on their own. The inevitable outcome to anyone having a stroke at older ages is scary. I have been having the tough talks with my aging parents. Making certain wishes in their current Will and POA paperwork is still what they want. I am watching them fade and decline and it isn't easy to watch. My mom was recently diagnosed with Dementia, and I see her struggles are worsening.
Ask yourself if you are certian you know without doubt what she wants, and then stick to that. No matter how difficult it may be, you will make it through and life will go on. My best to you in this, and your best to your mom, your love for her shows.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Bgreen7777
Report

I applaud you for seeking answers to help you make this difficult decision. This should be all about your mother's values and what she would want. Someone with a DNR, DNI probably values quality of life over quantity. You tried the tube that she pulled out, you say accidentally, but are you sure? Doctors will keep her alive, no matter what. Being your mother's POA is a hard job emotionally, and you are grieving the mother you knew before the stroke, making the choices even more heart-wrenching. My brother-in-law had a similar stroke 9 years ago at age 49. They kept him alive against our better judgment, but he has no life and will never have any quality of life. Another option is not to allow antibiotics if she gets an infection. She will have a peaceful death in a short time. None of these decisions are easy, so follow your heart.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to altheahal
Report

No feeding tube should be in the DNR. So sorry for your loss. It is terrible that this happenened so fast to your mom. I am afraid there is no turning back. Your mom needs to rest in peace.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Onlychild2024
Report

A problem with feeding tubes is once inserted its very hard to get them removed. Because its then considered starving someone. The only was to get it removed is bringing in Hospice.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

My wife has had a feeding tube (PEG) for 3 years; one replacement year two.

Current placement is too high on stomach.

But for PEG, she would not be alive today.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to GreystoneBill
Report
swmckeown76 Feb 3, 2025
Thank you for valuing her life and her for valuing her life so much that she's willing to have the PEG tube. This is an individual decision, of course, but it's wonderful to see people not see something like a feeding tube as overly burdensome.
(0)
Report
My mom is COMPLETE DNR for thinks like stroke, heart attack. We treat for things like pneumonia, high BP. Typically feeding tubes should be addressed with the DNR. I do know that once a feeding tube is in it is difficult to get it out - stop feedings.... So, if she can have pureed, maybe just go that route and not have it put back in?
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to jules925
Report

Can you ask her? Anyone with a DNR already in place would most likely not want a feeding tube long term. What is her rehab potential? Getting over a hump isn’t a bad idea because she’ll need nutrition to rehab but if her potential is poor, just stop and call for a hospice consult.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Jdjn99
Report

She has no Medical Power of attorney or living will saying no feeding tube?

My daughter is an RN and feels, in the elderly, feeding tubes should only be used to get you over a hump. Should never be used to keep someone alive.

You are going to need to see how things progress. I personally would not send someone to rehab with Moms feeding problems. Rehab is generally for Physical therapy. Its not Skilled Nursing, not where I live anyway.
If she worsens, I would ask for a Hospice evaluation.
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
MiaMoor Feb 1, 2025
Absolutely 100% to each point here.
(1)
Report
After my mother got her speech back (not very easy to understand) after her stroke, she said to my father (very haltingly), "Why didn't you let me die? This is not living." She lived three years after the stroke. They were not good years for her or for my father.

I'm sorry you are going through this, it is heartbreaking. I hope somehow your mom can communicate to you what she wants so you can have peace in any decisions you have to make.
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to graygrammie
Report

In my humble opinion--as a retired RN and 82 year old-- yes, you are delaying the inevitable.
How LONG the placement of a tube may delay it is anyone's guess, but you can, by providing this certain sustenance very, very long indeed.
Your message serves as a warning to ALL HERE. You may think you have a good advance directive, but if you do not make it clear to your proxy or POA that you do NOT want these life-prolonging measures they will be very hesitant to withhold and face the accusations of "you are starving your parent to DEATH". YOU will be right here, and if that's what you WANT, that's fine, but if you do not want dialysis, tube feedings, etc you had better make that very clear, indeed.

Back to your own mom, Stokedaughter. I am assuming that your mother is not able to respond to the questions about whether she wants to prolong her life or not?
Otherwise you would certainly have discussed this with HER, because this should, if she were competent at all, be HER CHOICE and HER CHOICE ALONE.

Now it is your choice. Once having started these feedings it is going to be much more difficult to stop and withdraw them. You would have to fight for that option as her POA and you had better lie like a rug--that she told you and others she didn't want this. Otherwise, if you believe that this is a life worth living, and that she would want to go on, you follow doctor advice as to when/if/how to get sustaining foods on board.

I wish you the very best, and I am so sorry you are going through this. I as an RN have LONG made it clear in my own advance directive that this, as well as other measures, would be anathema to me.
Helpful Answer (15)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
ElizabethAR37 Feb 2, 2025
Yes, to me as well!
(1)
Report
You can ask for a palliative care and hospice consult and discuss this with them since they will be able to read her charts and examine her.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Bulldog54321
Report

My mother had a sudden hemorrhagic stroke, taking her quickly from being fine to completely unable to do physically anything at all. She spent weeks in the hospital following the stroke during which time a team of doctors including neurologists encouraged us to have a feeding tube placed temporarily. We were told it would be temporary, a matter of weeks, as she went to rehab and regained abilities with therapy. As she was mentally intact and there was such encouragement of recovery, we had the feeding tube placed and off to rehab she went. She worked valiantly in rehab for months, all to almost no avail. There was no measurable progress. In Medicare world, therapists must be able to document progress in order to continue, they sadly told us though she tried so hard, therapy would end. She could eat puréed food for a while, over time that went away and became dangerous so all feeding became through the tube. She spent her days in a wheelchair after being placed in it. She was a two person assist for every move and reposition. She lost speech over time. There were likely more strokes, but no one had the heart to put her through MRI’s to confirm. She couldn’t read or watch tv. She lost vision in one eye. She couldn’t do even the simplest thing for herself, yet she remained aware and cognizant. I still haven’t seen anything more cruel. No one was willing to remove feeding from a mentally intact person, so on it went for four years. We all attempted to make the best of it. If my mom could have talked I’m confident she’d have wanted out of her life as it was.
As for you and your mom, I’m so very sorry. Can your mother communicate in any way? If so, please have an honest talk with her, telling her the possibilities and seeing if she can communicate her thoughts. Do you want the feeding tube? Squeeze my hand with your good hand for yes, blink three times for no—whatever you can make work that feels like you’re getting her wishes if possible.
Another thing is a realistic talk with her doctors, seeing if you can get honest conversation about the chances of meaningful recovery. We didn’t have this, I would hope others are more successful.
Mostly, rely on knowing your mother, knowing the person she is and what she would decide for herself. And whatever that is, once it’s done, spend no time doubting either way. She’s blessed to have you caring so much. I wish you both peace
Helpful Answer (29)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report
MiaMoor Feb 1, 2025
Oh my gosh, I'm so sorry for you and your family, but most of all for your mum.

I think this is a sad but timely warning of how important it is to consider whether we would want peg feeding in such circumstances, now while we are healthy and can consider the implications. Later on could be too late.
(1)
Report
I agree with Fawnby.

If it were me, and you were my daughter, I would like you to let me go.

Living with the effects of a stroke, AND a feeding tube would be TOO MUCH for me.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to cxmoody
Report

If I were in your mom’s situation, I would want you to leave me in peace and let me go. Let the inevitable happen.
That would be the kindest thing.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter