Follow
Share

It has been a while now since my mother passed from Alzheimer's.
I remember the hardest things for me was not that she suffered Alzheimer's but rather confronting my own awareness that I didnt wish to care for her, and that this was due to the abusive childhood I suffered and estranged adult relationship. There just wasnt a relationship there. It was painful to confront those bad memories and the realisation that I didnt really have a family, which was something I did not really think much of or often as it had been pushed aside in my mind. There was lots of pressure from other wider network family members who seemed shocked that I didnt adhere to the requests to caregiving time or money. I ended up providing some care, although it was more once every couple of weeks. And didnt provide any money. People were judgmental but they didnt know the reasons and rather saw it through their own lived family experience rather than mine. When she passed I didnt feel sad. Rather, I was relieved that her suffering was at an end. I didnt really feel like I had lost a mother as I never really thought much of having had one. Has anyone else had this kind of experience?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I told my parents right off the bat I'd not do any hands on caregiving for them or move them in with me. When my mother suggested it, "jokingly", I cleared up that misconception immediately.

To everyone else, my mother was sweetness and light. To the immediate family who knew her, she was mean, nasty and two faced. Which makes things much harder for US, because the act these women put on portray them only in a positive light. So obviously, we are the Bad Guys for not wanting much to do with them. Shrewd, isn't it?

A few times in Assisted Living moms mask fell off and the real her was on display for all to see. The caregiver was in tears and the nurse was white in the face with shock. Yeah huh? Welcome to MY WORLD folks!

I did a lot for my mother, but it wasn't hands on caregiving but managing her life instead. I ordered snacks for her, brought her clothes and necessities, arranged a pizza party with the grandkids, things like that.

When she passed at 95, I felt relief. That she was finally at peace after a life of misery, and I was off the hook for doing more for her. By that time, I was almost 65 and ready to stop all the jumping thru hoops I'd done as an only child my whole life. I'd never felt like I had much of a mother to begin with, right wrong or indifferent, and I'd grieved that loss long before she actually died.

You're not alone. Until the others who judged us walked in our shoes, they had no idea whatsoever of what our mothers were really like.
Helpful Answer (26)
Report
Anyonymous1 Aug 2024
I resonate with this completely. My mother was not the same way as she was to her friends. It was quite odd being at the funeral with all the stories told about her. I wasnt able to speak at the funeral. For me attendance was the most I could do.
(11)
Report
See 1 more reply
Even if you had a great childhood and a happy family, not everyone is cut out to be a hands-on caregiver, especially for their elderly parents. And there is NO SHAME in that.

Just as everyone isn't cut out to be a parent. Not every woman gets googly-eyed looking at infants. I myself would have been quite content if my husband had not wanted to have children. I love my two kids, and am so glad I had them, but the prospect of motherhood, at least to me, was "meh". I feel the same way about grandkids - I know there are people out there who just can't wait to have them. If my kids choose to have children, I'm sure I will love them, but I certainly won't feel any lack in my life if they choose to remain childless. Or feel as though my kids have somehow failed me by not supplying me with grands.

The point is, no one should feel compelled to or be forced to give care to another human being if it's just not in their wheelhouse to do so. Especially since there are other options at hand - maybe not perfect options, but options nonetheless.
Helpful Answer (22)
Report
Anyonymous1 Aug 2024
Yes this is true. Some people might find it a challenge even with having had a positive relationship. But then that is weighed against a sense of loyalty or duty. I didnt feel much of either to be honest.
(2)
Report
I was abused by both of my parents as a child and I knew that I would NEVER, as in NEVER take on any care of them as they aged.
Thankfully I lived many states away by that point, but even if I'd been in the same state/city, I would not have done anything.
And while I had forgiven my parents many years ago, I have no regrets and I like you honestly felt nothing when they both died. It was almost like they were people that I had known long ago and were now strangers which in reality they were.
And I had always said that if I were to cry when they died it would be for the parents that I never had and should have. But in my case, no tears were shed for either, ever.
It sounds cold to write that, but when there is abuse involved, we as survivors of that abuse must do what we need to to protect our mental health, and do what is best for ourselves.
Thankfully I've never been one who cares what other people think about me and what I should or shouldn't be doing, so that was never an issue that I had to deal with, and I really like the person that I have grown to be despite years of abuse.
God turns ALL things into good for those who love Him, and love Him I do.
I pray for only good things for you as well.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report
Anyonymous1 Aug 2024
Sorry to hear about your experiences. I only had one abusive parent. But my father who was not abusive died when I was 11. I think that might be part of what caused my mother behave the way she did. Doesnt excuse it though.
(6)
Report
I didn’t have anything like your experience. One of the first and most valuable things I learned on this forum, was how many people had painful and difficult childhood experiences that followed them long into adulthood. My childhood wasn’t perfect but I was blessed to always be cared for and loved. You made the right choices for you. Caregiving is already impossibly hard, doing it for someone you don’t have a strong, loving relationship with, well, I just cannot imagine how hard. I’m sorry you, and so many others, didn’t have the mother you needed and deserved, and wish you all peace
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

Hi Anonymous - I just wanted to say that I think yours is such an important post - and I also thank those who have responded and shared their input and experiences ...because I really found strength in reading this.

Sending much love ~
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
Anyonymous1 Aug 2024
Thanks for your kind post. I feel less alone reading the comments. Not something I can talk about with many in the real world.
(8)
Report
See 1 more reply
I had a good mom. My Dad was a good Dad but had some problems I think stemmed from his Dad and maybe a slight mental problem. He pushed buttons and could step over the line being cruel. Did not instill confidence in his kids. That could be not graduating high school. I loved him, but I told my brothers I will not care for him. TG he went before Mom. I cared for her for 20 months till I could place her. She was easy, it was me. I like order to things. Rules. I can work around personalities if the people are consistant. But Dementia is too unpredictable. You never know what is going to happen. I was lucky Mom adjusted to care.

You should never care for anyone who abused you.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

As someone else said, whatever your situation growing up, if you are not the “caregiver” type, you shouldn’t have to be. I get the guilt though. My parents moved in to an addition to live with us… that said, I refuse to do anything related to toileting or bathing. It give me the icks. Don’t want to. And that’s it. I also told my parents MANY years ago that I would never be as hands on with them as my mother was with her own (talking about grandmas diaper rash, washing, etc… blech). Well, my dad still expected it but now knows he better not asking me to clean poop. And there’s a lot of poop. Mom also refused to shower with caregiver for almost 3 weeks. They had to send in a different caregiver to try and were successful. Did I feel guilty that I didn’t step in and try? Yes. But the ick was stronger than the guilt. I do plenty of other stuff. All legal, financial, trips to docs, etc.
In addition to my own job, husband, 3 kids, and most importantly, caring for my own mental health which is in shambles since this all started. I’m in therapy. It’s more venting than anything else. My husbands mother also has dementia. He’s an only child. My sister is in Florida and NO help.
Bottom line, id rather go to therapy for my guilt than do something I REALLY don’t want to do.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

You did nothing wrong .
If anything , you did it right , you did it right by setting boundaries and limiting the time you spent with your mother .

Those others had no right to expect you to do more .

As you said , your mother’s end of life has brought up issues regarding your upbringing . I recommend speaking to a therapist .

Again, you did it right rather than allowing yourself to be sucked into a situation you should not have been forced to do , nor were you comfortable with. Like you said others did not understand because their experience was different .

And yes , many of us with abusive parents like you did not set good enough boundaries like you did due to the pressure and being judged by others and sufferered for it .

Everything you are feeling is perfectly normal , including feeling relieved .

You’ve got this.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
Anyonymous1 Aug 2024
Thanks for your comments. I do feel at peace with the approach I took.
(6)
Report
I would never judge anyone for what they do, don't do, did or didn't do.
I do not have the FULL story or history behind the relationship to make a sound judgement.

You can ignore the people that say "you should do this or that" or the ones that say "I would have done this or that"
A simple way to stop this is to say...
"Great I am glad you can help out, I will see you on Tuesday at 10, you can take care of Carol while I do some errands"

You owe no one an explanation so don't even bother.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
faithfulbeauty Aug 2024
Great answer! None of the people that judged me offered their help.
(2)
Report
My parents divorced when I was 18 and married people who were much better suited to them. Growing up was very difficult with a mom with a volatile temper and alcoholism, and a father who was rigid (didn’t speak to my brother for three years because he wanted to make a living as a guitarist) and basically shrugged his shoulders in regard to our family. We all moved away —the closest sibling was over 500 miles away. Me—2000. We’ve been diagnosed with complex PTSD.

My mom had colon cancer the last 14 months of her life. I couldn’t afford to go see her and for whatever reasons my brothers didn’t go either. I am forever grateful that her stepfamily took care of her. Their relationship with her was completely different from ours and I’m sure they couldn’t figure out why we didn’t go see her. We were sad but it was evident that people who came to her funeral had a whole different experience of her. But I was relieved that I wasn’t going to be subjected to her unpredictable criticism over the phone. My dad died five days after entering the hospital at the age of 88. His wife took wonderful care of him. In past conversations my brothers had with her, she didn’t believe dad was the way they described him. When my father died neither my brothers nor I cried when he died. You can’t miss what you never had. I shudder to think about the prospect of caregiving either of them. Years of therapy taught me how toxic they were and I had to preserve my mental health.

I’m sure there are residents in nursing homes who have no visitors and people wonder why. We don’t know the story. Some are indeed forgotten or have no family. But others abused their children.

You have nothing to feel guilty about. Others did not walk in your shoes. There have been very sad entries here from caregivers who took care of abusive parents. The abuse got worse and they were incredibly worn out, sad and angry.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
MiaMoor Aug 2024
I get cross when I hear criticism of children who don't visit their aged parents. As you say, we don't know the reasons why and it could be that the sweet old lady, or dear old man, was a horrible person when they were younger.

I was cross when one of my Mum's carers told me to visit my mum more often, and that I will miss her one day.
I love my mum, but I had my reasons for only visiting once a week (sometimes less) despite living within walking distance. They're my reasons and I don't have to explain myself to anyone else. Nor do I need to feel guilty.
(10)
Report
See All Answers
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter